logo logo

We are three brothers and two sisters. My elder sister was married on 3.8.1989, and has one son.  Another sister was married on 5.11.1995, and has no issues. We three brothers are living together as joint family in an ancestral house and have inherited ancestral property of our grandfather. Our parents have expired. Now my sisters are demanding shares in ancestral property including the house and have threatened to file a partition suit.  As we would like to settle the issue amicably, please advise us.

- by Ramamurthy, Kollagal

Earlier, the daughters had no rights in Co-parcenery property that is joint family property as per Hindu Succession Act 1956; later on various states amended the Hindu succession act conferring equal rights to daughters.

Karnataka state has amended Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act which came into force from 30th July 1994. Section 6A of the Act, provides equal rights to daughters and they are entitled to equal share. But, the amendment clearly states that the provisions of the amendment do not apply to daughters married prior to the commencement of Hindu Succession (Karnataka amendment) Act 1990.

In the light of the above facts your elder sister, who was married on 3.8.1989 is not entitled to any share in joint family property but your younger sister who was married on 5.11.1995 is entitled to equal share. Another interesting factor is your ancestral dwelling house where all the three brothers are said to be residing and according to section 23 of Hindu succession Act, the female heir cannot force partition of such house until the male members opt for partition. As such your younger sister cannot force the partition of ancestral dwelling house.

What I have dealt above is the legal position. But since you are for amicable settlement all the brothers and younger sister may voluntarily give some part of the property to the elder sister to maintain cordial family relationship.


These are all the legal questions answered by Advocate S.Selvakumar in various magazines, in various occasion including realestate reporter monthly.


Q:- I had purchased a house in Basaveshwarnagar, which I had bequeathed to my only daughter. The will is registered. Unfortunately my daughter is suffering from serious heart problem and needs hospitalization and surgery. The doctor has informed that the entire process may cost two lakh and some additional amount for post operation treatment. I want to mortgage my house which is willed to my daughter and avail loan. Please advise whether it is possible?

Q:- Mr. and Mrs. Mallappa had made a Will before their demise stating that the property should not be sold to any third party and should be purchased by their children only. Now, I have entered into an agreement with one of the children of Late Shri Mallappa. Whether can I go ahead to purchase a property or withdraw from the agreement?

Q:- I own a property jointly with my sister which is acquired by both of us out of our own funds. I am aged and my sister is taking care of me as my children have abandoned me. Please inform how I can transfer my share in the property to my sister without much expenditure in my lifetime?

Q:- Whether Hindu Widow can alienate property through will to a particular son, which is acquired by her through her husband, out of other sons?

Q:- I am given to understand that my paternal uncle has bequeathed his house in Bangalore to me through a Will. But, my uncle has not confirmed this and the Will which is registered is kept in safe custody by my uncle. Though I have applied for a certified copy of the Will, the registrar refused to provide me a copy. Please inform how can I get a copy?